Factors Influencing Compliance and Degree
of Compliance to
Treatment Regimen among Hypertensive
Patients
Ms. Valarmathi. P
Lecturer, BMCB College of Nursing, Bhuj- Kuchchh, Gujarat.
Corresponding
Author Email: ammuvalar@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Background: Hypertension or high blood pressure
affects at least 1 billion people worldwide. It is a widespread health problem
affecting nearly 20% of the population in most countries. But its control is
still a challenge for physicians all around the world. Control of blood
pressure can reduce cardio vascular morbidity and mortality. So the compliance
to antihypertensive drugs and life style modification play an important role
for the control of hypertension.
Aim: To assess the factors influencing compliance and degree of compliance
to treatment regimen among hypertensive patients.
Materials and methods: A descriptive research design was selected. Total 60
patients were selected by non-probability purposive sampling technique. The
study was conducted in Chettinad hospital and Research Institute at
Kelambakkam, Tamilnadu. The data was collected by structured interview method
by using structured questionnaire including demographic data. To analyze the
data, descriptive and inferential statistics were used. Results:
The findings of the study revealed that with regard to the degree of compliance
41 (68.3%) patients were non-compliant and 19 (31.7%) patients were compliant
to treatment regimen. Researcher found that there was a significant difference
between the means of socio economic factors (p=0.02), motivational factors
(p=0.03) and treatment related factors (0.03) with respect to medication. There
was a significant difference between the means of socio economic factors
(p=0.001) and motivational factors (p=0.001) with respect to diet. There was a
significant difference between the means of socio economic factors (p=0.001),
motivational factors (p=0.001) and cognitive factors (p=0.001) with respect to
exercise. There was a significant difference between the means of socio
economic factors (p=0.001) and cognitive factors (p=0.001) with respect to
regular checkup. Researcher also found that there was a significant association
between the degree of compliance and the demographic variables of age,
education and income.
Conclusion: Socio Economic Factors, Motivational Factors,
Treatment Related Factors were the major contributors for noncompliance with
medication. Socio economic factors, Motivational Factors were the contributors
for non-compliance with diet. Socio
economic Factors, Motivational Factors and cognitive Factors were the
contributors for noncompliance with exercise. Socio economic Factors and
cognitive Factors were the contributor for noncompliance with regular checkup.
KEY WORDS: Assess,
factors influencing compliance, treatment regimen, hypertensive patients.
INTRODUCTION:
Hypertension is the medical term for high blood pressure. It is
considered to be present when a person’s systolic blood pressure is
consistently 140 or more and their diastolic BP is consistently 90 mmHg or
more. It is one of the most common worldwide disease affecting humans. Because
of the associated morbidity and mortality and the cost to society, hypertension
is an important public health challenge.1
Uncontrolled and prolonged elevation of BP can lead to a variety of changes in
the myocardial structure, coronary vasculature, and conduction system of the
heart. These changes in turn can lead to the development of left ventricular
hypertrophy (LVH), coronary artery disease (CAD), various conduction system
diseases, and systolic and diastolic dysfunction of the myocardium,
complications that manifest clinically as angina or myocardial infarction,
cardiac arrhythmias (especially atrial fibrillation) and congestive heart
failure (CHF).2
Hypertensive
heart disease was estimated to be responsible for 1.0 million deaths worldwide
in 2004 (or approximately 1.7% of all deaths globally), and was ranked 13th in
the leading global causes of death for all ages. It is a common chronic disease
amenable to control by appropriate medication or adopting relevant lifestyle
modifications. Adherence to therapeutic lifestyle measures reduces the risk of
cardiovascular problems. Non-compliance can worsen the quality of life and add
to the cost of medical care.3
NEED FOR THE STUDY:
Hypertension or high blood pressure
affects at least 1 billion people worldwide. It is a widespread health problem
affecting nearly 20% of the population in most countries. But its control is
still a challenge for physicians all around the world. Control of blood
pressure can reduce cardio vascular morbidity and mortality. So the compliance
to antihypertensive drugs and life style modification play an important role
for the control of hypertension.4
Thomas Dennis,
(2006) found that
half of the Indian patients were not adherent to their antihypertensive regimen
and this might result in poor blood pressure control. Non-adherence to
hypertension management remains a major limiting factor among Indians in the
effective control of hypertension and in the prevention of cardiovascular
diseases.5
Kaplan,
et.al., (2006) identified the multiple reasons for the poor blood pressure (BP)
control rates such as age, gender, low socioeconomic status and
severity of disease, class of drug prescribed, number of pills per day, side
effects of medication, patient’s inadequate understanding of the disease and
importance of the treatment, co-morbid medical conditions, lack of social support,
poor patient- care provider relationship, cost, forgetfulness, and presence of
psychological problems especially depression had all been shown to affect
adherence in various populations.6
According
to NCD camps analysis, (2011) found that one in every five persons in Chennai
is hypertensive. A majority are unaware of it. And even though undergoing
treatment, they do not have their condition under control.7 Hence the
investigator felt that if the factors influencing compliance to treatment
regimen has been found out, the health care workers could help to rectify those
problems.
STATEMENT
OF THE PROBLEM:
A
study to assess the factors influencing compliance and degree of compliance to
treatment regimen among Hypertensive Patients in a Selected Tertiary Hospital,
Tamilnadu, India.
OBJECTIVES:
·
To
assess the factors influencing compliance to treatment regimen among
hypertensive patients.
·
To
assess the degree of compliance to treatment regimen among hypertensive
patients.
·
To
associate the degree of compliance to treatment regimen with selected
demographic variables of hypertensive patients.
OPERATIONAL
DEFINITION:
Assess:
·
It refers to the
exploration of the factors influencing compliance and degree of compliance to
treatment among hypertensive patients who are attending medical OPD with the
structured questionnaire.
Factors Influencing
Compliance:
·
It refers to the
factors such as socio economic factors, motivational factors, treatment related
factors and cognitive factors, which are making the patients as non-adherent to
treatment regimen.
Degree of Compliance:
·
It refers to how
for the patients are adherent to treatment regimen.
Treatment Regimen:
·
It refers to
regular drug, regular exercise (at least 30 minutes thrice per week), eating
salt and fat free diets and regular checkup.
Hypertensive Patients:
·
It refers to the
Patients who were diagnosed as having baseline hypertension (>140/90 mmHg)
minimum one year before.
Hypotheses:
H1: There will be a significant difference
between the factors influencing compliance to treatment regimen among
hypertensive patients.
H2: There will be a significant association
between the degree of compliance to treatment regimen and selected demographic
variables of hypertensive patients.
MATERIALS
AND METHODS:
Research Approach:
A
quantitative research approach was considered appropriate for the present
study.
Research Design:
A
non-experimental descriptive research design was adopted for this study.
Setting of the study:
The
study was conducted in Chettinad hospital and research institute, medical OPD,
Kelambakkam, Tamilnadu.
Population:
In
the present study, the target population was Hypertensive Patients.
Sample:
Hypertensive
patients who were attending medical OPD at CHRI and fulfilling the sampling
criteria.
Sample size:
The
present study comprised of 60 hypertensive Patients.
Sampling technique:
Non-probability
purposive sampling technique was used for selecting samples for this study.
Criteria for Sample Selection:
a) Inclusion criteria:
o
The patients who
were placed on anti hypertensive treatment for at least one year prior to data
collection.
o
The patients
whose age was between 20 and 80 years.
o
The patients who
were mentally sound.
o
The patients who
were attending medical OPD in CHRI.
o
The patients who
were willing to participate in the study.
b) Exclusion criteria:
o
The patients who
were too sick.
o
The patients who
could not give informed consent.
o
The patients who
had complications of hypertension.
Description
of the tool:
The
tool consisted of two sections.
Section-A:
It
consisted of 10 items of demographic variables like age, sex, education,
occupation, income, marital status, type of family, area of residence, duration
of hypertension, present BP.
Section-B:
Questionnaire-I:
The
structured questionnaire-I consisted of 36questions, to assess the factors
influencing compliance. These 36 questions were classified under 4 parts. Socio
economic factors consisted of 7 questions. Motivational factors consisted of 20
questions. Treatment related factors consisted of 4 questions. Cognitive
factors consisted of 4 questions. Each part consisted of aspects like drug,
diet, exercise and regular checkup. The first 31 questions had two options Yes/
No. The next 4 questions were choose the correct answer type.
Questionnaire-II:
The
tool was a five point Likert scale consisted of 5 options namely always,
sometimes, once in a while, rarely, and never to assess the degree of
compliance to treatment regimen. It consisted of 15 items.
Data analysis:
The
data analysis included both descriptive and inferential statistics. The
collected data was organized, tabulated and analyzed based on the objectives of
the study by using descriptive statistics (Percentage, mean, standard
deviation) and inferential statistics (Chi-square test and f test).
Ethical consideration:
The
research proposal was approved by the ethical committee of Chettinad University
prior to conduct the pilot study and main study. The written permission
obtained from the Dean and medical superintendent of CHRI. Written consent was
obtained from each participant before data collection.
RESULTS:
Ř There was significant difference between
the means of socio economic factors (p=0.02), motivational factors (p=0.03) and
treatment related factors (0.03) with respect to medication.
Ř There was significant difference between
the means of socio economic factors (p=0.001) and motivational factors
(p=0.001) with respect to diet.
Ř There was a significant difference between
the means of socio economic factors (p=0.001), motivational factors (p=0.001)
and cognitive factors (p=0.001) with respect to exercise.
Ř There was a significant difference between
the means of socio economic factors (p=0.001) cognitive factors (p=0.001) with
respect to regular checkup.
Ř Among 60 samples 41 (68.3%) patients were
non-compliant to treatment regimen and 19 (31.7%) patients were compliant to
treatment regimen.
Ř There was significant association between
the degree of compliance and the demographic variables of age (p=0.003),
education (p=0.004) and income (p=0.003).
Fig 1: Percentage
distribution of degree of compliance
DISCUSSION:
·
First
objective of the study to assess the factors influencing compliance to
treatment regimen among hypertensive patients.
H1: There will be a significant difference
between the factors influencing compliance to treatment regimen among
hypertensive patients.
The result has shown that there is significant difference between
the means of socio economic factors, motivational factors and treatment related
factors with respect to Medication. There is no significant difference with
respect to cognitive factors. There is significant difference between the means
of socio economic factors and motivational factors. There is no significant
difference with respect to cognitive factors with respect to diet. There is a
significant difference between the means of socio economic factors,
motivational factors and cognitive factors with respect to exercise. There is a
significant difference between the means of socio economic factors cognitive
factors with respect to regular checkup. But there is no significant difference
with respect to motivational factors. Hence the researcher accepted the
research hypothesis. Findings are supported by the research conducted by Kabir,
et al. in Murtala Mohammed Specialist Hospital in Kano, Nigeria.8
·
Second
objective of the study to assess the degree of compliance to treatment regimen
among hypertensive patients.
H2: There will be a significant association
between the degrees of compliance to treatment regimen with selected demographic
variables of hypertensive patients.
There is a significant association between the degree of
compliance and the demographic variables of age, education and income. Hence
the researcher accepted the research hypothesis.
CONCLUSION:
Based
on the findings of the study Socio economic Factors, Motivational Factors,
Treatment Related Factors, were the major contributors for non-compliance with
medication. Socio economic Factors and Motivational Factors were the
contributors for non-compliance with diet.
Socio economic Factors, Motivational Factors and cognitive Factors were the
contributors for non-compliance with exercise. Socio economic Factors and
cognitive Factors were the contributors for non-compliance with regular
checkup.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
·
Additional
research is needed to further explain the mechanism through which the factors
and hypertension are related.
·
An
experimental study to determine the effectiveness of the structured information
booklet on patients with hypertension.
NURSING IMPLICATIONS:
·
Lack
of motivation is one among the major factors why the patients are
non-compliance. Therefore attempts must be made to motivate the patients as
well as their relatives in adhering to treatment regimen.
·
Nurses
must educate the hypertensive patients regarding the complications of
uncontrolled hypertension.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
I wish to
express my heartfelt gratitude and sincere thanks to our respected Dr. Ms.
Rajalakshmi, MBBS., DPM. I profusely thank her for valuable suggestions and
guidance from the beginning to the end of the study.
REFERENCES:
1.
Brounwald. E, 1984. A Text Book of Cardiovascular Medicine.
W.B Saunders Company. Philadelphia.
2.
Lewis, et. al., 2000. Medical Surgical Nursing. 7thedit.
Mosby publication. Philadelphia.
3.
Indian twin epidemic study, 2012. Prevalence of non
communicable diseases. Indian Journal of Chest Diseases and Allied
Sciences.Vol.1.(Retrieved from http//www.pubmed.com)
4.
Maleka Sarour, 2006.Barriers associated with adherence to
life style modification. Journal of Health and Social Behavior.Vol.1.
5.
Dennis, 2006.
Medication adherence in hypertensive patients. (Retrieved May 8, 2006 from
http//www.bupa.com)
6.
Kaplan, et. al., 2007. Factors influencing compliance with
adherent to life style modification. National Medical Journal of India.Vol.2.
7.
NCD, 2012.Prevalence of hypertension. Times of India.
(Retrieved from http//www.pubmed.com )
8.
Kabir, et. al., 2005. Factors influencing compliance and
degree of compliance to anti hypertensive treatment. Niger Post Graduate
Medical Journal.Vol.1.
Received on 12.02.2015 Modified on 11.04.2015
Accepted on 24.04.2015 ©
A&V Publication all right reserved
Int. J. Nur. Edu. and Research
3(2): April-June, 2015; Page 163-166